Skip to content

Dubstep Brostep Comparison Essay

"Tempa" redirects here. For other uses, see Tempa (disambiguation).

Dubstep is a genre of electronic dance music that originated in South London, England. It emerged in the late 1990s as an offshoot of UK garage, drawing on a lineage of related styles such as 2-step, dub reggae, techno, broken beat, and jungle.[1][2] The music generally features sparse, syncopated drum and percussion patterns with bass lines that contain prominent sub-bass frequencies. In the United Kingdom the origins of the genre can be traced back to the growth of the Jamaican sound system party scene in the early 1980s.[2][3]

The earliest dubstep releases date back to 1998, and were usually featured as B-sides of 2-step garage single releases. These tracks were darker, more experimental remixes with less emphasis on vocals, and attempted to incorporate elements of breakbeat and drum and bass into 2-step. In 2001, this and other strains of dark garage music began to be showcased and promoted at London's night club Plastic People, at the "Forward" night (sometimes stylised as FWD>>), which went on to be considerably influential to the development of dubstep. The term "dubstep" in reference to a genre of music began to be used by around 2002 by labels such as Big Apple, Ammunition, and Tempa, by which time stylistic trends used in creating these remixes started to become more noticeable and distinct from 2-step and grime.[4]

A very early supporter of the sound was BBC Radio 1 DJ John Peel, who started playing it from 2003 onwards. In 2004, the last year of his show, his listeners voted Distance, Digital Mystikz, and Plastician in their top 50 for the year.[5] Dubstep started to enter mainstream British popular culture when it spread beyond small local scenes in late 2005 and early 2006; many websites devoted to the genre appeared on the Internet and aided the growth of the scene, such as dubstepforum, the download site Barefiles and blogs such as gutterbreakz.[6] Simultaneously, the genre was receiving extensive coverage in music magazines such as The Wire and online publications such as Pitchfork, with a regular feature entitled The Month In: Grime/Dubstep. Interest in dubstep grew significantly after BBC Radio 1 DJ Mary Anne Hobbs started championing the genre, beginning with a show devoted to it (entitled "Dubstep Warz") in January 2006.[7][8][9]

Towards the end of the 2000s and into the early 2010s, the genre started to become more commercially successful in the UK, with more singles and remixes entering the music charts. Music journalists and critics also noticed a dubstep influence in several pop artists' work. Around this time, producers also began to fuse elements of the original dubstep sound with other influences, creating fusion genres including future garage, the slower and more experimental post-dubstep, and the harsher electro house and heavy metal influenced brostep, the latter of which greatly contributed to dubstep's popularity in the United States.[10]


Dubstep rhythm example

Excerpt demonstrating the rhythmic tension generated between the drum rhythm and bassline. This song features a very sparse rhythm almost entirely composed of kick drum, snare drum, and a sparse hi-hat, with a distinctly half time implied 71bpm tempo. The track is instead propelled by a sub-bass following a four-to-the-floor 142bpm pattern.

Problems playing this file? See media help.

The music website Allmusic has described Dubstep's overall sound as "tightly coiled productions with overwhelming bass lines and reverberant drum patterns, clipped samples, and occasional vocals."[11] According to Simon Reynolds, Dubstep's constituents originally came from "different points in the 1989—99 UK lineage: bleep 'n' bass, jungle, techstep, Photek-style neurofunk, speed garage, [and] 2 step."[2] Reynolds comments that the traces of pre-existing styles "worked through their intrinsic sonic effects but also as signifiers, tokenings-back addressed to those who know".[2]

Dubstep's early roots are in the more experimental releases of UK garage producers, seeking to incorporate elements of drum and bass into the South London-based 2-step garage sound. These experiments often ended up on the B-side of a white label or commercial garage release.[7][12][13] Dubstep is generally instrumental. Similar to a vocal garage hybrid – grime – the genre's feel is commonly dark; tracks frequently use a minor key and can feature dissonant harmonies such as the tritone interval within a riff. Other distinguishing features often found are the use of samples, a propulsive, sparse rhythm,[14] and an almost omnipresent sub-bass. Some dubstep artists have also incorporated a variety of outside influences, from dub-influenced techno such as Basic Channel to classical music or heavy metal.[14][15][16]


Dubstep rhythms are usually syncopated, and often shuffled or incorporating tuplets. The tempo is nearly always in the range of 138–142 beats per minute, with a clap or snare usually inserted every third beat in a bar.[14] In its early stages, dubstep was often more percussive, with more influences from 2‑step drum patterns. A lot of producers were also experimenting with tribal drum samples, such as Loefah's early release "Truly Dread" and Mala's "Anti-War Dub".

In an Invisible Jukebox interview with The Wire, Kode9 commented on a MRK1 track, observing that listeners "have internalized the double-time rhythm" and the "track is so empty it makes [the listener] nervous, and you almost fill in the double time yourself, physically, to compensate".[17]

Wobble bass

One characteristic of certain strands of dubstep is the wobble bass, often referred to as the "wub", where an extended bass note is manipulated rhythmically. This style of bass is typically produced by using a low-frequency oscillator to manipulate certain parameters of a synthesiser such as volume, distortion or filter cutoff. The resulting sound is a timbre that is punctuated by rhythmic variations in volume, filter cutoff, or distortion. This style of bass is a driving factor in some variations of dubstep, particularly at the more club-friendly end of the spectrum.[18]

Structure, bass drops, rewinds, and MCs

Originally, dubstep releases had some structural similarities to other genres like drum and bass and UK garage. Typically this would comprise an intro, a main section (often incorporating a bass drop), a midsection, a second main section similar to the first (often with another drop), and an outro.

Many early dubstep tracks incorporate one or more "bass drops", a characteristic inherited from drum and bass. Typically, the percussion will pause, often reducing the track to silence, and then resume with more intensity, accompanied by a dominant sub-bass (often passing portamento through an entire octave or more, as in the audio example). It is very common for the bass to drop at or very close to 55 seconds into the song, because 55 seconds is just over 32 measures at the common tempo of 140 bpm. However, this (or the existence of a bass drop in general) is by no means a completely rigid characteristic, rather a trope; a large portion of seminal tunes from producers like Kode9 and Horsepower Productions have more experimental song structures which do not rely on a drop for a dynamic peak – and in some instances do not feature a bass drop at all.

Rewinds (or reloads)[19] are another technique used by dubstep DJs. If a song seems to be especially popular, the DJ will "spin back" the record by hand without lifting the stylus, and play the track in question again. Rewinds are also an important live element in many of dubstep's precursors; the technique originates in dub reggaesoundsystems, is widely employed by pirate radio stations and is also used at UK garage and jungle nights.[20]

Taking direct cues from Jamaica's lyrically sparse deejay and toasting mic styles in the vein of reggae pioneers like U-Roy, the MC's role in dubstep's live experience is critically important to its impact.[21]

Notable mainstays in the live experience of the sound are MC Sgt Pokes and MC Crazy D from London, and Juakali from Trinidad.[22][23][24][25] Production in a studio environment seems to lend itself to more experimentation. Kode9 has collaborated extensively with the Spaceape, who MCs in a dread poet style. Kevin Martin's experiments with the genre are almost exclusively collaborations with MCs such as Warrior Queen, Flowdan, and Tippa Irie. Skream has also featured Warrior Queen and grime artist JME on his debut album, Skream!. Plastician, who was one of the first DJ's to mix the sound of grime and dubstep together,[15] has worked with notable grime setup Boy Better Know as well as renowned Grime MC's such as Wiley, Dizzee Rascal and Lethal Bizzle. He has also released tracks with a dubstep foundation and grime verses over the beats.[26] Dubstep artist and label co-owner Sam Shackleton has moved toward productions which fall outside the usual dubstep tempo, and sometimes entirely lack most of the common tropes of the genre.[27]


Throughout the history of dubstep since it was in the underground it has served as a dominant sonic and social force in the establishment of a sub cultural identity.[28]


1999–2002: origins

The early sounds of proto-dubstep originally came out of productions during 1999–2000 by producers such as Oris Jay,[16]El-B,[12] Steve Gurley[12] and Zed Bias.[29][30] Ammunition Promotions, who run the influential club night Forward>> and have managed many proto-dubstep record labels (including Tempa, Soulja, Road, Vehicle, Shelflife, Texture, Lifestyle and Bingo),[8][16] began to use the term "dubstep" to describe this style of music in around 2002. The term's use in a 2002 XLR8R cover story (featuring Horsepower Productions on the cover) contributed to it becoming established as the name of the genre.[29][31]

Forward>> was originally held at the Velvet Rooms in London's Soho and later moved to Plastic People in Shoreditch, east London.[14] Founded in 2001, Forward>> was critical to the development of dubstep, providing the first venue devoted to the sound and an environment in which dubstep producers could premier new music.[32] Around this time, Forward>> was also incubating several other strains of dark garage hybrids, so much so that in the early days of the club the coming together of these strains was referred to as the "Forward>> sound".[33] An online flyer from around this time encapsulated the Forward>> sound as "b-lines to make your chest cavity shudder."[34]

Forward>> also ran a radio show on east London pirate station Rinse FM, hosted by Kode9.[35] The original Forward>> line ups included Hatcha, Youngsta, Kode 9, Zed Bias, Oris Jay,[16] Slaughter Mob, Jay Da Flex, DJ Slimzee, and others, plus regular guests. The line up of residents has changed over the years to include Youngsta, Hatcha, Geeneus, and Plastician, with Crazy D as MC/host. Producers including D1, Skream and Benga make regular appearances.[32]

Another crucial element in the early development of dubstep was the Big Apple Records record shop in Croydon.[8] Key artists such as Hatcha and later Skream worked in the shop (which initially sold early UK Hardcore / Rave, Techno and House and later, garage and drum and bass, but evolved with the emerging dubstep scene in the area),[12] while Digital Mystikz were frequent visitors. El-B, Zed Bias, Horsepower Productions, Plastician, N Type, Walsh and a young Loefah regularly visited the shop as well.[8] The shop and its record label have since closed.[29]

2002–05: evolution

All throughout 2003, DJ Hatcha pioneered a new direction for dubstep on Rinse FM and through his sets at Forward>>.[8][30] Playing sets cut to 10" one-off reggae-style dubplates, he drew exclusively from a pool of new South London producers—first Benga and Skream,[30] then also Digital Mystikz and Loefah—to begin a dark, clipped and minimal new direction in dubstep.[36]

At the end of 2003, running independently from the pioneering FWD night, an event called Filthy Dub, co promoted by Plastician, and partner David Carlisle started happening regularly. It was there that Skream, Benga, N Type, Walsh, Chef, Loefah, and Cyrus made their debuts as DJs. South London collective Digital Mystikz (Mala and Coki), along with labelmates and collaborators Loefah and MC Sgt Pokes soon came into their own, bringing sound system thinking, dub values, and appreciation of jungle bass weight to the dubstep scene.[29] Digital Mystikz brought an expanded palette of sounds and influences to the genre, most prominently reggae and dub, as well as orchestral melodies.[37]

After releasing 12-inch singles on Big Apple, they founded DMZ Records, which has released fourteen 12"s to date. They also began their night DMZ, held every two months in Brixton,[38] a part of London already strongly associated with reggae.[39] DMZ has showcased new dubstep artists such as Skream, Kode 9, Benga, Pinch, DJ Youngsta, Hijak, Joe Nice, and Vex'd. DMZ's first anniversary event (at the Mass venue, a converted church) saw fans attending from places as far away as Sweden, the United States, and Australia, leading to a queue of 600 people at the event.[40] This forced the club to move from its regular 400-capacity space[9] to Mass' main room, an event cited as a pivotal moment in dubstep's history.[16][41]

In 2004, Richard James' label, Rephlex, released two compilations that included dubstep tracks – the (perhaps misnamed) Grime and Grime 2. The first featured Plasticman, Mark One and Slaughter Mob,[42] with Kode 9, Loefah, and Digital Mystikz appearing on the second.[43] These compilations helped to raise awareness of dubstep at a time when the grime sound was drawing more attention,[29] and Digital Mystikz and Loefah's presence on the second release contributed to the success of their DMZ club night.[44] Soon afterwards, the Independent on Sunday commented on "a whole new sound", at a time when both genres were becoming popular, stating that "grime" and "dubstep" were two names for the same style, which was also known as "sublow", "8-bar", and "eskibeat".[45]

2005–08: growth

In the summer of 2005, Forward>> brought grime DJs to the fore of the line up.[46] Building on the success of Skream's grimey anthem "Midnight Request Line", the hype around the DMZ night and support from online forums (notably[14] and media,[9] the scene gained prominence after former Radio 1 DJ Mary Anne Hobbs gathered top figures from the scene for one show, entitled "Dubstep Warz", (later releasing the compilation albumWarrior Dubz).[40] The show created a new global audience for the scene, after years of exclusively UK underground buzz.[14]Burial's self-titled album appearing in many critics' "Best of ..." lists for the year, notably The Wire's Best Album of 2006.[47] The sound was also featured prominently in the soundtrack for the 2006 sci-fi film Children of Men,[48] which included Digital Mystikz, Random Trio, Kode 9, Pressure and DJ Pinch.[49] Ammunition also released the first retrospective compilation of the 2000–2004 era of dubstep called The Roots of Dubstep, co-compiled by Ammunition and Blackdown on the Tempa Label.[50]

The sound's first North American ambassador, Baltimore DJ Joe Nice helped kickstart its spread into the continent.[14] Regular Dubstep club nights started appearing in cities like New York,[51] San Francisco,[31] Seattle, Montreal, Houston, and Denver,[52] while Mary Anne Hobbs curated a Dubstep showcase at 2007's Sónar festival in Barcelona.[16] Non-British artists have also won praise within the larger Dubstep community.[16] The dynamic dubstep scene in Japan is growing quickly despite its cultural and geographical distance from the West. Such DJ/producers as Goth-Trad, Hyaku-mado, Ena and Doppelganger are major figures in the Tokyo scene.[53] Joe Nice has played at DMZ,[54] while the fifth instalment of Tempa's "Dubstep Allstars" mix series (released in 2007) included tracks by Finnish producer Tes La Rok and Americans JuJu and Matty G.[55]

Techno artists and DJs began assimilating dubstep into their sets and productions.[16] Shackleton's "Blood on My Hands" was remixed by minimal techno producer Ricardo Villalobos (an act reciprocated when Villalobos included a Shackleton mix on his "Vasco" EP)[56] and included on a mix CD by Panoramabar resident Cassy.[16]Ellen Allien and Apparat's 2006 song "Metric" (from the Orchestra of Bubbles album),[57][58]Modeselektor's "Godspeed" (from the 2007's Happy Birthday! album, among other tracks on that same album) and Roman Flugel's remix of Riton's "Hammer of Thor" are other examples of dubstep-influenced techno.[16] Berlin's Hard Wax record store (operated by influential[59] dub techno artists Basic Channel)[60][61] has also championed Shackleton's Skull Disco label, later broadening its focus to include other dubstep releases.[15]

The summer of 2007 saw dubstep's musical palette expand further, with Benga and Coki scoring a crossover hit (in a similar manner to Skream's "Midnight Request Line") with the track "Night", which gained widespread play from DJs in a diverse range of genres. BBC Radio 1 DJ Gilles Peterson named it his record of 2007, and it was also a massive hit in the equally bassline-orientated, but decidedly more four-to-the-floor genre of bassline house,[62] whilst Burial's late 2007 release Untrue (which was nominated for the 2008 Nationwide Mercury Music Prize in the UK) incorporated extensive use of heavily manipulated, mostly female, 'girl next door' vocal samples.[63] Burial has spoken at length regarding his intent to reincorporate elements of musical precursors such as 2-step garage and house into his sound.[64]

Much like drum and bass before it, dubstep started to become incorporated into other media. In 2007, Benga, Skream, and other dubstep producers provided the soundtrack to much of the second series of Dubplate Drama, which aired on Channel 4 with a soundtrack CD later released on Rinse Recordings. A track by Skream also featured in the second series of the teen drama Skins, which also aired on Channel 4 in early 2008.[65]

In the summer of 2008, Mary Anne Hobbs invited Cyrus, Starkey, Oneman, DJ Chef, Silkie, Quest, Joker, Nomad, Kulture and MC Sgt Pokes to the BBC's Maida Vale studios for a show called Generation Bass. The show was the evolution from her seminal BBC Radio 1 Dubstepwarz Show in 2006, and further documented another set of dubstep's producers.[66][67][68][69]

As the genre has spread to become an international rather than UK-centric scene, it has also seen a number of women making headway into the scene in a variety of ways. Alongside Soulja of Ammunition Promotions and Mary Anne Hobbs, an influx of female producers, writers, photographers and DJs all have broken through in the up-til-then male orientated scene. With key 12" releases on Hyperdub, Immigrant and Hotflush Recordings, producers Vaccine, Subeena and Ikonika have introduced a palette of new sounds and influences to the genre, such as double-time bass drums, 8-bitvideo game samples, hand percussion and lushly arranged strings.[70] Mary Anne Hobbs commented that, unlike "Grime and drum 'n' bass raves, the mood at dubstep nights is less aggressive, or more meditative, leading to a larger female attendance at events than with the genre's precursors. You see the female-to-male ratio constantly going up – it's got the potential to be 40:60".[70]

2009–present: mainstream influence

The influence of dubstep on more commercial or popular genres can be identified as far back as 2007, with artists such as Britney Spears using dubstep sounds; critics observed a dubstep influence in the song "Freakshow", from the 2007 album Blackout, which Tom Ewing described as "built around the 'wobbler' effect that's a genre standby."[71][72]Benga and Coki's single "Night" still continued to be a popular track on the UK dance chart more than a year after its release in late 2007, still ranking in the top five at the start of April 2008 on Pete Tong's BBC Radio 1 dance chart list.[73]

However, the year 2009 saw the dubstep sound gaining further worldwide recognition, often through the assimilation of elements of the sound into other genres, in a manner similar to drum and bass before it. At the start of the year, UK electronic duo La Roux put their single "In for the Kill" in the remix hands of Skream.[74][75] They then gave remix duties of "I'm Not Your Toy" to Nero and then again with their single "Bulletproof" being remixed by Zinc. The same year, London producer Silkie released an influential album, City Limits Vol. 1, on the Deep Medi label, using 1970s funk and soul reference points, a departure from the familiar strains of dub and UK garage.[76] The sound also continued to interest the mainstream press with key articles in magazines like Interview, New York, and The Wire, which featured producer Kode9 on its May 2009 cover. XLR8R put Joker on the cover of its December 2009 issue.[77][78][79]

In April 2009, UKF Dubstep, a YouTube channel brand was founded by Luke Hood which introduced Dubstep to many young generations internationally at the time. UKF Dubstep has exploded in popularity as the music genre has hit the mainstream. In November 2010, the channel had 100,000 subscribers, now its sits at over one million.[80] "UKF features established and up and coming producers from around the world, featuring artists from Flux Pavilion / Knife Party to Friction / Hybrid Minds. We’re sent a huge amount of music so it’s our job to pick the best to upload on the channel for our audience to listen to. In just over 3 years our channels now have more than 2m subscribers and 4 channels – UKF Dubstep, Drum & Bass, Music and Mixes. The audience is getting more and more International and younger." Luke said on the interview with SoSoActive.[81]

In a move foreshadowed by endorsements of the sound from R&B, hip-hop and recently, mainstream figures such as Rihanna, or The Bomb Squad's Hank Shocklee,[82]Snoop Dogg collaborated with dubstep producers Chase & Status, providing a vocal for their "underground anthem", "Eastern Jam".[83] The 2011 Britney Spears track "Hold It Against Me" was also responsible for promoting dubstep tropes within pop music.[84] Rihanna's Rated R album released such content the very year dubstep saw a spike, containing three dubstep tracks.[85] Such events propelled the genre into the biggest radio markets overnight, with considerable airplay.[86] Other hip-hop artists like Xzibit added their vocals to dubstep instrumental tracks for the mixtape project Mr Grustle & Tha Russian Dubstep LA Embrace The Renaissance Vol. 1 Mixed by Plastician.[86][87] In summer 2009, rapper and actress Eve used Benga's "E Trips"; adding her own verses over the beat to create a new tune called "Me N My"; the first single on her album Flirt. The track was co-produced by Benga and hip hop producer Salaam Remi.[88][89]

Throughout 2010, the presence of dubstep in the pop charts was notable, with "I Need Air" by Magnetic Man reaching number 10 in the UK singles chart. This presented a turning point in the popularity of mainstream dubstep amongst UK listeners as it was placed on rotation on BBC Radio 1.[90] "Katy On a Mission" by Katy B (produced by Benga) followed, debuting at number 5 in the UK singles chart, and stayed in the top 10 for five more weeks.[91] Also in 2010, American producer Skrillex achieved moderate commercial success in North America with a dubstep-influenced sound. By 2011 his EP Scary Monsters and Nice Sprites had peaked at number three on the U.S.Billboard Dance/Electronic album charts.[92] In February 2011, Chase & Status's second album No More Idols reached No. 2 in the UK album chart.[93] On 1 May 2011, Nero's third single "Guilt" from their album reached number 8 in the Official UK Singles Chart.[94]DJ Fresh and Nero both had number one singles in 2011 with "Louder" and "Promises".[95] Strong baselines imported from dubstep continued in popular music with the Taylor Swift song I Knew You Were Trouble, which made number 1 on Billboard's U.S. Mainstream Top 40 chart.[96][97]

Further development and decline


See also: List of post-dubstep musicians and Bass music

In early 2011, the term "post-dubstep" (sometimes known as bass music) was used to describe urban music that was influenced by certain aspects of dubstep.[98] Such music often references earlier dubstep productions as well as UK garage, 2-step and other forms of underground electronic dance music.[99][100][101] Artists producing music described as post-dubstep have also incorporated elements of ambient music and early R&B. The latter in particular is heavily sampled by three artists described as post-dubstep: Mount Kimbie, Fantastic Mr Fox and James Blake.[102][103] The tempo of music typically characterised as post-dubstep is approximately 130 beats per minute.[98]

The breadth of styles that have come to be associated with the term post-dubstep preclude it from being a specific musical genre. Pitchfork writer Martin Clark has suggested that "well-meaning attempts to loosely define the ground we're covering here are somewhat futile and almost certainly flawed. This is not one genre. However, given the links, interaction, and free-flowing ideas ... you can't dismiss all these acts as unrelated"[98] The production duo Mount Kimbie is often associated with the origination of the term post-dubstep.[104] English music producer Jamie xx released remixes which are considered post-dubstep, including We're New Here (2011), a Gil Scott-Heron remix album.[99]

Brostep and American developments

In 2011, dubstep gained significant traction in the US market, by way of a post-dubstep style known as brostep, with the American producer Skrillex becoming something of a "poster boy" for the scene.[105][106][107] In September 2011, a Spin Magazine EDM special referred to brostep as a "lurching and aggressive" variant of dubstep that has proven commercially successful in the United States.[108] Unlike traditional dubstep production styles, which emphasise sub-bass content, brostep accentuates the middle register and features "robotic fluctuations and metal-esque aggression".[109] According to Simon Reynolds, as dubstep gained larger audiences and moved from smaller club-based venues to larger outdoor events, sub-sonic content was gradually replaced by distorted bass riffs that function roughly in the same register as the electric guitar in heavy metal.[110]

The term brostep has been used by some as a slight pejorative descriptor for a style of popular Americanised dubstep.[105] US and Canadian artists often drew inspiration from British brostep producers who tended to work less with sub-bass and more with mid-range sounds such as Caspa, Rusko, and Vex'd.[111] Rusko himself claimed in an interview on BBC Radio 1Xtra that "brostep is sort of my fault, but now I've started to hate it in a way ... It's like someone screaming in your face ... you don't want that."[112] According to a BBC review of his 2012 album Songs, the record was a muddled attempt by Rusko to realign his music with a "Jamaican inheritance" and distance it from the "belching, aggressive, resolutely macho" dubstep produced by his contemporaries.[113]

Commenting on the success of American producers such as Skrillex, Skream stated: "I think it hurts a lot of people over here because it's a UK sound, but it's been someone with influences outside the original sound that has made it a lot bigger. The bad side of that is that a lot of people will just say 'dubstep equals Skrillex'. But in all honesty it genuinely doesn't bother me. I like the music he makes."[114] Other North American artists that were initially associated with the brostep sound were Canadian producers Datsik and Excision. Their production style has been described by Mixmag as "a viciously harsh, yet brilliantly produced sound that appealed more to Marilyn Manson and Nine Inch Nails fans than it did to lovers of UK garage".[115] The brostep sound also attracted the attention of metal bands. Nu metal band Korn's 2011 album The Path of Totality features several collaborations with electronic music producers, including Skrillex and Excision.[116]


By 2016, the genre had declined drastically in popularity, particularly in the United States, where many formerly successful dubstep artists became most popular. Artists such as Skrillex, for instance, moved on to producing tracks for trap and pop artists,[117][118][119] while artists such as Mount Kimbie and James Blake shifted their sounds from post-dubstep into more experimental or soulful electronic influenced music.[120][121]

See also


  1. ^AllMusic - Dubstep "Absorbed and transfigured elements of techno, drum'n' bass and dub"
  2. ^ abcdReynolds, S.(2012),Energy Flash: A Journey Through Rave Music and Dance Culture, Perseus Books; Reprint edition (5 Jan 2012), pages 511–516, (ISBN 978-1-59376-407-4).
  3. ^The Big Big Sound System Splashdown, New Musical Express, 21 February 1981, ISSN 0028-6362.
  4. ^IMO Records "Hatcha Biography"Archived 12 January 2012 at the Wayback Machine., IMO Records, London, 17 October 2011. Retrieved 22 November 2011.
  5. ^"Keeping It Peel: Festive 50s – 2004". BBC Radio One. BBC. Retrieved 31 March 2011. 
  6. ^Wilson, Michael (1 November 2006). "Bubble and Squeak: Michael Wilson on Dubstep". Artforum International. Retrieved 31 March 2011. 
  7. ^ abde Wilde, Gervase (14 October 2006). "Put a Bit of Dub in Your Step". The Daily Telegraph. London. Retrieved 31 March 2011. 
  8. ^ abcdeO'Connell, Sharon (4 October 2006). "Dubstep". Time Out London. Time Out Group. Retrieved 21 June 2007. 
  9. ^ abcClark, Martin (16 November 2006). "The Year in Grime and Dubstep". Pitchfork. Retrieved 21 June 2007. 
  10. ^Joe Moor. "Dubstep: How Has It Become So Popular?". The Edge. 
  11. ^"Explore Music: Dubstep". AllMusic. Rovi Corporation. Archived from the original on 29 April 2012. Retrieved 31 March 2011. 
  12. ^ abcd"The Primer: Dubstep". The Wire (279). April 2011. ISSN 0952-0686. 
  13. ^Pearsall (18 June 2005). "Interview: Plasticman". Retrieved 31 March 2011. 
  14. ^ abcdefgMcKinnon, Matthew (30 January 2007). "South London Calling". Canadian Broadcasting Corporation. Archived from the original on 8 December 2011. Retrieved 31 March 2011. 
  15. ^ abcClark, Martin (23 May 2007). "Grime / Dubstep". Pitchfork. Retrieved 14 July 2007. 
  16. ^ abcdefghijSande, Kiran (7 June 2007). "Dubstep 101". Resident Advisor. Retrieved 31 March 2011. 
  17. ^"Invisible Jukebox". The Wire (269). July 2006. ISSN 0952-0686. 
  18. ^Clark, Martin (6 November 2009). "The Year in Grime / Dubstep: The Year in Dubstep, Grime, and Funky 2009". Pitchfork. Retrieved 1 April 2011.  
  19. ^"Interview: Joe Nice". GetDarker. 15 August 2006. Archived from the original on 28 September 2007. Retrieved 31 March 2011. 
  20. ^Clark, Martin (14 July 2006). "The Month In: Grime/Dubstep". Pitchfork. Archived from the original on 13 January 2009. Retrieved 31 March 2011. 
  21. ^Earp, Matt (30 August 2006). "Low End Theory: Dubstep Merchants". XLR8R. Amalgam Media. Archived from the original on 22 May 2011. Retrieved 31 March 2011.
Dubstep producer Skream, one of the most widely known names on the scene since the beginning of the Dubstep movement.
Dubstep Section at Black Market Records, Soho, London.

This time interest in electronic dance music, and particularly dubstep, has grown more organically, through raves, D.J. tours and especially the Internet. It has become a live-music juggernaut: This year’s Electric Daisy Carnival, a three-day electronic music festival in Las Vegas, featuring dubstep stars like Skrillex, Rusko and Datsik, drew 230,000 people. The similarly inclined Ultra Music Festival in Miami drew 150,000. (By comparison Bonnaroo and Coachella attracted about 80,000 each.) Enthusiasm isn’t confined to major metropolitan areas. Skrillex headlined a tour this fall of clubs and theaters, with capacities of 1,000 to 4,000, that included stops in Syracuse; El Paso; Lawrence, Kan.; and Spokane, Wash.

Korn is one of many mainstream rock, pop and hip-hop acts exploring dubstep. Snoop Dogg, Lil Wayne, Rihanna, Britney Spears and J. Cole have all worked dubstep-flavored beats and sounds into recent tracks. Jay-Z and Kanye West built “Who Gon Stop Me?,” from this summer’s “Watch the Throne,” around a sample from the British dubstep D.J. Flux Pavilion. Skrillex has created dubstep remixes for Lady Gaga, Katy Perry and the Black Eyed Peas; this year he collaborated with the surviving members of the Doors for “Breakn’ a Sweat,” the first track the band worked on together in 30 years.

Even Justin Bieber recently revealed that he’s experimenting with dubstep for his next album.

“Dubstep is the new punk, the new metal, the new rock; it’s what kids are fiending for,” said Saul Milton of the British duo Chase & Status, who have produced, remixed or collaborated on dubstep-leaning tracks by Snoop Dogg, Rihanna, Jay-Z and Cee Lo Green. “The tempo is great for rappers and singers. You’ve got a lot of space in the drums, which allows for vocals and crazy bass noises.”

Dubstep dates to the early 2000s in Britain. The word is an amalgamation of dub, as in Jamaican dub reggae, and 2-step, an underground electronic music subgenre that emphasizes unconventional dance beats. Early dubstep tracks by Skream and Burial were generally atmospheric and nuanced, but as the genre has grown in popularity, particularly in North America, it has transformed into a noisy, aggressive, testosterone-heavy spectacle that detractors refer to pejoratively as bro-step. Skrillex, who was born Sonny Moore, has become, fairly or unfairly, the face of bro-step, and dubstep purists see his work with Korn as the culmination of the genre’s bigger-is-better trend.

Skrillex, who was recently nominated for five Grammys, collaborated with Korn on three tracks for “The Path of Totality,” including the first single, “Get Up.” He said he is accustomed to seeing the comment section below his YouTube videos become a forum for naysayers to express their profanity-laced disapproval. “You could have 200 pages of people ripping something apart, then I can drop ‘Get Up!’ at Electric Daisy Carnival in front of 100,000 people, and every single person will go off on it,” he said.

Korn’s own fans have been skeptical of its new direction. One typical comment on the popular metal Web site Blabbermouth, which is maintained by Korn’s label, Roadrunner Records, summed it up thus: “Alienate most of your current or past fans. Just to jump on a new bandwagon. I call sell out!”

Mr. Davis said: “A lot of people say I was doing this to jump on the bandwagon, but I’ve been a huge dubstep fan for years. I could retire easily right now, but we love challenging ourselves. My main focus is to attract the electronic crowd because they’re more open-minded.”

That Korn’s new path emerged at a moment that seemed a creative and commercial ebb for the band and a pinnacle for dubstep certainly invites charges of opportunism, but these charges say as much about the conservativeness of rock and metal as it does about Korn itself. When the popular metal band Five Finger Death Punch issued a bonus CD of dubstep-influenced remixes with the deluxe edition of its 2011 album, “American Capitalist,” the reaction was similarly polarizing, the band’s guitarist Zoltan Bathory said.

“Hardcore fans reject anything that changes the band’s sound so they hated it,” he said. “Metal fans are generally purists. If you look at metal from the ’80s and today, fundamentally it’s the same four instruments, guitar, bass, drums, vocals. If you use electronic influences, especially influences that are the flavor of the year, fans look at this as changing the very fundamentals of the genre.”

In late October a link to the Doors’ collaboration with Skrillex was posted to the band’s Facebook page. The negative reactions outnumbered positive ones by at least six to one.

“Any time you do anything different, Doors fans are upset,” said the Doors keyboardist, Ray Manzarek. He noted that the band was criticized for its 1969 album, “The Soft Parade,” because it used horns and strings. “You can’t touch the Doors,” he added. “There’s a sacredness about Jim Morrison, especially now that he’s dead. But we’re open to all avenues of life. Working with Skrillex is just another avenue.”

Pop and hip-hop fans seem significantly less concerned about dubstep’s creeping influence. That performers like Rihanna, Britney Spears, Jay-Z and Kanye West are incorporating the hottest new sounds is generally seen as a virtue not a crime. In pop and hip-hop, stagnation equals death. Verse Simmonds, a co-producer of “Who Gon Stop Me?” from “Watch the Throne,” said he had learned about dubstep just weeks before working on the song.

“It’s that new wave everybody is really moving to right now,” he said. “I think it could be something fresh and new that’s in hip-hop for a while.”

The criticism of Korn’s turn to dubstep notwithstanding, some fans are clearly being won over. “Get Up!” has sold more than 200,000 digital downloads. During a five-song stretch devoted to “The Path of Totality” at the band’s concert at Wild Bill’s the energy hardly flagged, even though the audience had never heard much of the material. The monstrous bass drops and squawking beats in songs like “My Wall” and “Kill Mercy Within” didn’t feel at all out of place amid Korn’s punishing, down-tuned riffs and swaggering rhythms. Mosh pits materialized in front of the stage.

Some Korn fans will still see “The Path of Totality” as a betrayal of its roots, and dubstep diehards will undoubtedly blanch at Korn — or Rihanna or Justin Bieber — co-opting the music. Yet if history is a guide, the music will continue to evolve despite the concerns of either camp.

“In a year’s time the hype may die down, but that doesn’t mean dubstep will go anywhere,” Mr. Milton said. “Right now in America you’ve got kids wide-eyed excited, trying to find the next rave. This is just the beginning.”

Continue reading the main story
Correction: December 25, 2011

An article on Dec. 11 about the heavy-metal band Korn and its incorporating dubstep, a kind of electronic dance music, into its sound misspelled the surname of the band’s guitarist who is known as Munky. He is James Shaffer, not Schaffer.